Excellent emotionally charged movie. Very suspenseful. Beautifully filmed

Another great Taylor Sheridan script. An important film featuring an impeccable cast

Taylor Sheridan’s flair for creating heartland epics is undimmed, but it’s hard not to wonder what someone with more directing chops, and the will to hit the accelerator, would have done with it.

Andrew Lowry

Empire

The movie's strength is Sheridan's knack for vivid characterization through little more than casual remarks and consistent voices.

Sheridan knows how to craft a tidy whodunit – and a late-act switch in perspective works better than it should – but he eventually leans toward sermonizing instead of storytelling, a well-intentioned move that edges the story just this close to melodrama.

Barry Hertz

The Globe and Mail (Toronto)