Atom User Reviews for I Can Only Imagine 2 - Early Access Screening

4.8
1285
117
36
12
10
POPULAR TAGS
JM
Jill Miller
#inspiring
#familyfriendly
#truestory

I hadn’t seen the first movie so really didn’t expect to enjoy this one much, but I did. The cast was good and the fact that it’s a true story really made it resonate with me. No matter how bad things may be going for you, there’s always someone who has it worse AND there…

LM
Lori Mejaly
#inspiring
#mustsee
#greatcast

Amazing!!! Inspiring and emotional. A MUST SEE!

DM
Denine Martin

I was an extra in the Tim Timmons part of the movie and was completely blown away by the final result .

HR
Hadassah Roach
#everyone
#inspiring
#truestory

FABULOUS Movie!!!! Everyone must see

MS
Michelle Shaffer
#heartwarming
#inspiring
#mustsee

I absolutely enjoyed this movie and by the end was singing and crying!

LH
Lauren Holmes
#inspiring
#truestory
#mustsee

This was such a powerful, inspiring story; it resonated with us deeply. My husband and I both cried during the film and we highly recommend everyone see it! God is in the fire.

KS
Kimberly Sasha
#inspiring
#mustsee
#familyfriendly

Amazing movie! Made me cry and my kids loved it. Really great for teens and music lovers. Love to see Jesus movies make it on the big screen! 10/10

MP
Misty Perez
#inspiring
#mustsee

Beautiful story

AU
Ana Urizar
#truestory
#familyfriendly
#inspiring

everybody must have to see.

MC
Marilyn Cates
#excellent
#inspiring
#truestory

Will go again

KB
Kati Brandon
#mustsee
#inspiring

Amazingly heartfelt!

RR
Rick Roselló
#inspiring
#truestory
#mustsee

God is in the fire with us. What a beautiful story. No matter where we are in life, God is always there. Great personal story.

RG
Robert Glandon
#greatcast
#heartwarming
#mustseebro

This is one of the best movies I’ve ever seen.!

DZ
Donna Ziebell
#mustsee
#truestory
#great

Great movie very heartwarming and will tell friends to go see the movie.

RS
Rachel Secrest
#inspiring
#mustsee

This was a great movie I would highly recommend but might want to bring tissues will have you in your feelings.

JC
James Chei
#mustsee
#inspiring
#truestory

Loved the movie. Very inspirational and touching.

AD
Asnath Deolus
#mustseebro
#original
#truestory

I love this movie so much. So powerful. Serving God is real!

RF
Ruth Forney
#inspiring
#mustsee
#familyfriendly

Did not disappoint in any way! Great movie.

PM
Patricia Maestas
#mustsee
#familyfriendly
#inspiring

##Amazaing

CK
Courtney Kelley
#inspiring
#mustsee
#familyfriendly

Great, must see movie. This is so inspiring and exactly what the world needs right now.

NS
Noemi Salinas
#inspiring
#truestory
#mustsee

This movie was so good! It has you feeling several different emotions throughout which I wasn't expecting. I highly recommend making time to see this film.

KA
Kelly Anderson
#mustsee
#truestory
#familyfriendly

Fantastic Movie! Love hearing the true story about the song “Even If”. I have always loved the lyrics to the song. A must see movie for the family.

JS
JACKIE SZADKOWSKI
#mustsee

This was an absolute delight. The whole movie was captivating and there was never a dull moment. It makes it even better, knowing that is it based on a true story.

GY
Gary Yerks
#inspiring
#truestory
#great

Good movie, great continuation of the MercyMe story.

JB
Jacqueline Beatty-Hobbs
#inspiring
#mustsee
#seeingitagain

Amazing movie!!!

AS
Amber Smith
#memorable
#inspiring
#mustsee

Better than the first and worth going to see again in theaters. It's a great story and has a great message.

AC
April Cannon
#seeingitagain
#mustsee
#great

We people don’t see any other movie this year. This one should be it.

KE
kyle edmunds
#truestory
#allthefeels

All the feels all the time.

SS
Susan Schwemmer
#lovedthemovie
#inspiring
#truestory

My husband was deeply touched. Rethinking his relationship with our sons

JS
Jeff Staddon
#inspiring
#truestory
#mustsee

This is a fabulous movie. It has all the elements to be a great movie. It is a tearjerker, makes you feel for a number of the people It shows you the ups and downs that a family goes through and how they overcome the problems.

EK
Evelyn Kokotkiewicz
#greatcast
#seeingitagain
#inspiring

it is a wonderful, heartfelt movie that moved me to tears and also had me laughing out loud.

KH
Karen Holm
#inspiring
#mustsee

Excellent movie! Highly recommend for you to go see it!

MA
Michelle Alvarado
#allthefeels

Truly a wonderful movie based off real life events. Very moving with great trials and tribulations. Lots of good laughs!

SM
Stacy Murphy
#inspiring
#mustsee
#seeingitagain

Outstanding movie. So glad we went to see it - highly recommend!!

SC
Sabrina Chappell
#inspiring
#mustsee
#truestory

This 2nd installment continues to uplift and restore your faith in the higher power, but mainly believing in yourself and trusting hope. The world needs more of these films. This is part of the solution to fight against the negative.

SB
Sara Brenneis
#mustsee
#truestory
#familyfriendly

A really great movie

MW
Marti Wilson

I wasn’t expecting a 15 minute “intro” to the movie especially after sitting through 25 minutes of previews. My 5 pm movie didn’t start until 5:45. The movie was hard to follow in places and we considered leaving.

AB
Annu Bhatia
#slow

I liked the story line alot. just a little bit slow.

NA
Noah Aster

A lot doesn’t fit in the film and jumps to situations too quickly.

PV
Paul Vogel
#slow
#boring
#creepy

Waste of time

RR
Rachel Riether
#inspiring
#mustsee

Awesome movie. A must see.

CS
Carol Steffen
#mustsee
#familyfriendly
#inspiring

Awesome movie!! Thank you

AT
Alina Teplinsky
#great
#inspiring
#original

Great true story

TP
Tammy Parlin
#seeingitagain
#mustsee
#truestory

Usually sequels are not as good as the first - this movie is an exception- just as wonderful as the first!!! Loved it SO much :-)

EK
Ed Kruse
#inspiring
#truestory

You will laugh and you will cry but you will leave a better person. Fantastic movie.

HM
Heidi Marie
#mustsee
#truestory
#allthefeels

Excellent Heartfelt movie!

KA
Kate Alexander
#inspiring
#greatcast

Very emotionally engaging. Stirs the soul. Acting was really good and film was well made.

DS
Don Schmitt
#inspiring

They should make more like this.

AT
Arlene Teague
#t1dwithgodsstrength
#inspiring
#mustsee

Bring your tissues!

AP
Alisa Prokopchuk
#inspiring
#truestory
#mustsee

Such a good movie. When music inspired. I like how the story of boy-father relations was told.

Metacritic

75
Feb 20, 2026

This movie is designed for an audience already dedicated to the music of Millard and Timmons, and to the particular Christian tradition they represent. Those who are already fans will appreciate this chance to share his story, but those who do not know him may find it uninspiring.

Metacritic review by Nell Minow
Nell Minow
RogerEbert.com
60
Feb 19, 2026

Ventimiglia becomes the sequel’s saving grace.

Metacritic review by Lisa Kennedy
Lisa Kennedy
The New York Times
30
Feb 19, 2026

Laborious and dull, I Can Only Imagine 2 only comes to life in the comedic scenes featuring Ventimiglia, who buries his handsomeness in a buzz-cut, full beard, and Buddy Holly-style glasses to resemble Timmons.

Metacritic review by Frank Scheck
Frank Scheck
The Hollywood Reporter