Bad Education (Hei de jiào yù)

#補標 ㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ 以畫外旁白破題，畫面逼仄地特寫大口吃食蝦蟹魚肉的嘴，營造不適感。這幀畫面將海鮮作為人／弱者的象徵，油膩的唇齒則是強者、握有力量者、壞人。柯震東初執導筒的成果展現，令人驚喜的是他懂得揚長避短，妥善利用特寫鏡頭突出表演的優點，並在表演較弱的片段採用較寬鬆的鏡頭尺寸，輔以剪輯減少缺點的暴露（但印象中有一段對白剪輯與畫面對不上，算是滿明顯的剪輯失誤）。然而，有許多風格化的操作都有輸出過火而不知收斂的問題，比如過多且動機不明的zoom…

taiga ㊣

This review may contain Spoilers. Thought provoking and brutal Chinese film. On the night of their graduation 3 students offer up their darkest secrets. They are despicable acts that they supposedly committed. However, there is always the possibility that what your mind…

Des Saint

I was not expecting for the first chapter to be so insanely disturbing — graduation night gone extremely wrong, and days before graduation gone even more wrong ??? — but I was not expecting for the movie to shift tone all of a sudden either, so I guess it compensated for…

less

他們在畢業的那一晚黑化。 好久沒看到臺灣拍出這麼痛快俐落、生猛有力的類型電影，柯震東可以考慮轉行不當演員了（？），尤其靠著他的好人緣，處女作就請來這麼多有頭有臉的大人物來助陣，這製作規格要其他新導演怎麼跟得上？然後必須特別嘉許落日飛車的片尾曲，實在太有味道了。雖然九把刀的劇本還是逃不出極度中二的窠臼，不過當做是一個招牌的作者印記來看待，似乎也不是什麼壞事。反倒是既然都只拍77分鐘的片長了，感覺可以再稍微修剪拍成短片會更精煉一些。

MaxHuang

was looking forward to this to support kai ko's directorial debut and I did enjoy some of the stylistic choices and it builds up the tension quite nicely. but ultimately, the message wasn't conveyed well for me and the way it was wrapped up in the third chapter made me…

shi qin

เล่นเหี้ยไรนิวัยรุ่น

anglek

Reviewed for the Singapore Film Society, do check their blog out here!: https://www.singaporefilmsociety.com/film-review-bad-education --- Taiwan’s film industry has always been a passionate field of study for me, but admittedly I have lesser knowledge in more…

William Li

非常直覺會聯想到《報告老師，怪怪怪怪物！》（個人認為是九把刀目前最佳也最被嚴重低估的一部），而《黑的教育》在其中一些暴力又冒犯的惡趣味與招牌的戲謔中二電波，在刀大執筆的劇本下依舊存在，可是在柯震東演而優則導的巧手下，讓整部片不同與刀大的調調，反而更加節制且殘酷無比 精準的分為三章（猴子、好人、壞人），講述了一個「類似真心話大冒險玩過頭的奇譚寓言」，直球簡單也生猛有力，還頗有一絲A24《天黑請斃命》的荒誕味。巧合的是，《天黑》跟這部剛好都是講述友誼走向黑化崩壞的過程，只差在前者給出了令人哭笑不得的揭露，而後者走向了令人眼睛為之一亮的玉石俱焚。 …

Pony Chen

They deserved worse

safarrr