This material is so rich probably any halfway decent filmmaker could assemble a competent doc tallying the two men’s extraordinary accomplishments. But only Lizzie Gottlieb could make a film where she does that plus needles her pop about wearing sweatpants for his sit-down interview.

Kimberley Jones

Austin Chronicle

“Turn Every Page” is one step away from turning into a Herzogian monument to obsession or plunging into crazed psychodrama. Instead, it is merely a great profile, filled with wit, affection and detailed stories of how the books came to be.

Ben Kenigsberg

The New York Times

Though the documentary is clearly meant as a fan letter, not an even-handed report, it does overlook some important matters.

Kyle Smith

Wall Street Journal