Atom User Reviews for Practical Magic 2

4.6
124
29
6
6
2
POPULAR TAGS
JS
Jasmine Smith
#lovestory
#mustsee
#girlsnight

It was a good movie. Glad to have the ladies back together, that enough of a celebration for me.

KR
Kaya Rymwid-Mickiewicz

Overall disappointed. I loved the 1st movie and wanted to like this. Instead I spent most of the movie rolling my eyes at dialogue and other choices or throwing my hands up going "seriously?". There were a few touching scenes and some nice callbacks to the 1st movie. Thank…

CM
Courtney McCormack
#greatcast
#mustsee
#familyfriendly

Great sequel. Definitely holds up.

MW
Melissa Wittemann
#allthefeels
#mustsee
#seeingitagain

Honestly this was everything! Cried way more than I thought I would

CB
Christy Brehmer
#allthefeels
#greatcast

This was a very cute movie. If you love Practical Magic, you will this movie!

EZ
Eugeniya Zahava

Kind, captivating, amusing! Love, love, love it!! ❤️

RT
Ramona Tapia

it's was a good movie....

FV
francine villa

perfect

JS
Jacaia Stoffer

Love see the four witches I grew up watching and sad to lose two

PH
Paige H

The movie was good but the people in the seats in my aisle talked the entire time so I could not actually enjoy the movie

GM
God Emperor Mark Moreno

Total chick flick, also Aria Stark was in it for like 10 minutes total.

BD
Bonnie Damm

It’s basically a repeat of the first movie. What happened in the first movie is actually happening to the daughter instead of the sisters. Sally still treats her aunt awful. Ocourse it misses the pizzazz of the first movie.

PB
Priscilla Betts

Very sweet. Love it

JJ
Jan Jesky

one of the few sequels that actually outdid the original!

MV
Madeline Valdes

Such a cute and funny movie. Loved it.

AF
art fracchia

Holds true to the original

RH
Ron Honig

awesome special effects

HD
Heather D

Dialogue was ruff and the regression in Sally’s character was heartbreaking to watch in this sequel movie, also plot took too long to get through. I was hoping for better from this movie.

GW
Genola Walker
#mustsee
#allthefeels

Nostalgic feels

DG
Darryl Gainer
#lovestory
#greatcast

I thought the movie was ok, great to see the cast back together again for this sequel.

CM
Crystal Melmer
#lovestory
#girlsnight
#allthefeels

Great sequel! Worth the wait!

JS
Jannette Santana
#allthefeels
#greatcast
#mustsee

I love this movie ... it was so good ..

GR
Genova Rose
#allthefeels

nostalgic moment

NB
Ned Braff
#mustseebro
#greatcast
#heartpounding

An amazing sequel that was well worth waiting 26 years to experience! An amazing cast, an excellent story, and wonderful cinematography.

KS
Kellie Stray
#seeingitagain
#mustsee
#familyfriendly

Never a fan of sequels but this one is just as amazing as the first movie!!

NY
Nichole Young
#heartpounding
#familyfriendly
#seeingitagain

The perfect sequel.

AC
Angela Carter
#allthefeels
#greatcast

Loved this movie.

SH
Susan Hankins
#great

Loved it!

MJ
Matthew Johnson
#allthefeels
#girlsnight
#familyfriendly

loved it and coming to see another movie

GN
Gross Nina
#greatcast
#mustsee
#seeingitagain

Worth the 20 year wait!!

PM
Patricia Marm
#mustsee
#seeingitagain
#girlsnight

Perfect follow-up from the first one!!! So much fun!

DE
DENISE EMBRY
#mustsee
#familyfriendly
#seeingitagain

It was beautiful

TM
Teresa Miller
#mustsee
#seeingitagain
#familyfriendly

I really enjoyed it. It was better than the first one. I went with my daughters and my granddaughter and they all really liked the movie. I would give it five stars. It’s definitely a great movie.

MW
Matthew Walton
#allthefeels
#greatcast
#girlsnight

well done, definitely worth the wait.💖

HN
HarshaReddy N
#surprising
#fantasy
#seeingitagain

It’s predictable, but it’s really interesting and carried enthusiasm till the end perfectly

MA
Meli Alvz
#allthefeels
#greatcast

Loved it! If you loved the first one you will love this one just as much 🥰

NB
Naomi Baez
#mustsee
#familyfriendly
#allthefeels

It’s was great not a fan of the young male actor. Overall family was loving and sad.

TM
Taylor Marko
#boring
#slow

Stupid movie. It shouldn’t ever have been made. Why can’t Hollywood just leave films alone? Not everyone wants a sequel. But sure make a sequel, but make it terrible like this one was.

JG
Jeremy Guthrie
#allthefeels
#greatcast
#seeingitagain

I'm so glad they made a 2nd film. the first one is easily the top of my top 5 movies. I can put this one as my 3rd favorite. It had all the feels and the nostalgia required. The new elements were nice. I appreciated the attempt they made at pulling from the 4th book. The…

JM
Jackie Musacco
#allthefeels
#greatcast
#girlsnight

They did a good job gave all the fans what we wanted. It was worth the 29 years we waited.

JG
JOSE GUERRA
#mustseebro
#mustsee
#familyfriendly

Movie was amazing !!!!

DA
Deborah Aherne
#allthefeels
#girlsnight
#greatcast

Great sequel! Loved it

ST
Shanita Tolley
#seeingitagain
#onemoretime

This was so freaking good I loved the movie I’m sad it’s the end of it but they really played they’re parts

AD
Alicia Diaz
#allthefeels
#greatcast
#mustsee

big fan

RP
Ramon Perez
#allthefeels
#greatcast

Pretty good sequel after all these years. Far more action packed and way more magic!

PD
Pebbles Dr.
#greatcast
#girlsnight
#original

great followup!

AC
Amanda Cummings
#greatcast
#mustsee
#great

I loved it

BJ
Brittany Johnson
#great

really good movie

JM
Jorge Monsivais
#mustsee
#familyfriendly
#great

Waited 28 years for this sequel and it was worth the wait! Loved seeing Sandra & Nicole back on the the big screen, together! Es

CS
Cheryl Sandberg
#allthefeels
#greatcast

Metacritic

44
metacritic
Based on 41 Critics
tbd

USER SCORE (0)

There are no user reviews yet
30
Sep 12, 2026

While Bullock and Kidman return to their roles with the sisterly rapport necessary, the film itself is a closed circuit with no narrative electricity to power it.

Metacritic review by Angelica Jade Bastien
Angelica Jade Bastien
New York Magazine (Vulture)
38
Sep 10, 2026

For the most part, though, it’s an eminently forgettable product that is more interested in rehashing the first film’s familiar bits than in giving viewers any new ones of note.

Metacritic review by Peter Sobczynski
Peter Sobczynski
RogerEbert.com