My First Of May

理解新導演開不了這麼多組戲，能夠看得出在有限場景拍出來，但瑕疵很明顯。經常出現補「配音」的情況，有可能是只拍了幾take，然後都靠後期VO/後期修改對白了事。 剪接同劇本問題都蠻大。片長只有90分鐘，卻放了一半時間 focus…

Saiho ✌🏻

[Cinemasia 2025 #6] 近年已經有好多套一模一樣formula嘅戲，想請各位停止拍說教式嘅電影 I'm sick of seeing so many HK films recently with the same formula.

kya

Fairly standard Hong Kong slice-of-life drama about a family with an incredibly cursed medical history. Hits the right notes at the right times. Mainly watched for Aaron Kwok (who’s reliably decent as always), but it’s Natalie Hsu who’s the real standout here. [note: world…

Koen

印證咗用「可憐」弱勢出發點嘅電影，只會淪為煽情説教嘅產物。 可憐姿態角度寫人文關懷， 冇用心機好好塑造角色 變咗角色好刻板印象、表面唔立體 角色弧線唔明顯 就係好不妙。 主角鄧叔彥 養有肌肉萎縮嘅女兒，球賽亦被家庭影響失敗，離婚 種種對於「失敗家庭」嘅刻劃 只有略略帶過 甚至用對白刻劃 「有你呢個阿爸我好自豪 ，唔好為咗我放棄夢想呀」 「我自私」 「我好驚 我逃避」 呢啲對白都好老套同太直白 甚至變成解釋角色心理嘅對白 變咗好刻板印象、形式化…

tobey wong

CinemAsia Film Festival 2025 Film #5 - My First of May  My First of May by James Hung is an incredibly sappy drama, and when I say incredibly sappy, I mean sappy until a point it becomes eyeroll worthy. Which is really sad, as the acting in this film is quite good and it…

Taiyo

都係玩煽情但叫好過麥路人少少囉 唔係一味單純賣慘 但係果種臉譜化人物+全部戲劇衝突都係依賴對白既手法好TVB 而聽到周圍咁多紙巾聲我只能話真係打得中班目標觀眾 有幾場幾明顯睇得出係唔夾口型嘅後期配音 成套戲最好睇係鮑姐前1/3做死剩把口既嫲嫲 nat就還好 而我就真係完全入唔到城城個角色 即使對白有交代但始終理解唔到佢點解會咁樣逃避屋企 (散場後同朋友傾開覺得城城雖然造型上好放得開 但係講野口吻上都係未做到好”地”果種感覺 尤其對比私家偵探既古生)

KLY

Award baiting like no other. Some serious restructuring of the pre and post production teams need to be made

no longer joe

「拋球」那段戲是好的，但本片在攝影手法上一直都沒找到真的好的鏡位和運鏡方式，諸如父女吵架戲，除了對跳的爭執和有些尷尬的剪輯點，特意拍攝倒映的鏡頭也令人困惑。蒙太奇太多，凸顯敘事到後段的零散，而大事件基本都是靠病痛來撐。除了最後一場離世的戲處理得含蓄適宜。以題材來說，故事對疾病本身所作的生活細節經營明顯不足。鮑的表演有些用力過猛，郭似乎一直沒找到對的施力點。

CariChang

A victim forgiving their ex-perpetrator, in which they have full right to resent, seems to be the only true way towards inner peace. Though that seems opposite to justice, oftentimes there exists no clear path for that within broken relationships of decades of wrongdoing. A…

nezha3