Atom User Reviews for Mr. Malcolm's List

4.6 out of 5
40
14
3
2
0
POPULAR TAGS
#lovestory
#greatcast
#datenight
#girlsnight
#allthefeels
#<3
#familyfriendly
#great
#hilarious
#predictable
#mustsee
#smart
#inspiring
#surprising
Verified Review
#lovestory
#surprising
#great
#allthefeels
#<3

For those in love with Austen, Bronte, and Bridgerton---see this movie! It is sweet and funny, the characters very engaging and genuine. Will see again!

RB
Rachael B
Verified Review

So fun! Just like all the clean/sweet romance novels I like to read. The casting was weird/non traditional for a show like this. I’m all for colorblind/all body shapes casting, it just seemed like it was a little bit of a forced choice for this show. After a little bit, I didn’t care though. They all won me over and i just enjoyed a fun love story. Not for the snobbish and regency era purist types, but super enjoyable and I didn’t have to cover my daughter’s ears or eyes for any scenes. We laughed and sighed together. I love shows/stories like this. Good job!

AG
Aimee G
Verified Review
#lovestory
#<3

A must see for any regency romance fan!

KL
Katelyn L
Verified Review
#great
WT
William T
Verified Review
#allthefeels
SB
Susan B
Verified Review
#allthefeels
JC
Jessica C
Verified Review
NB
Nick B
Verified Review
#lovestory
#hilarious
#mustsee
#<3
#allthefeels
#mustseebro
#greatcast
AL
Alexandria L
Verified Review
LA
Luisa A
Verified Review
#lovestory
#predictable
#justokay
#boring
#girlsnight
JD
Jose D
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#great
NW
Nanette W
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#predictable
#<3
#allthefeels
AM
amor M
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#greatcast
NT
Nat T
Verified Review
AL
Andrea L
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
JL
Jenny L
Verified Review
#lovestory
#familyfriendly
#allthefeels
#greatcast
JD
jessika D
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
KB
Kevin B
Verified Review
#girlsnight
ZT
Zoe T
Verified Review
JB
Jenny B
Verified Review
#hilarious
#indiehit
#greatcast
VT
Victoria T
Verified Review
#girlsnight
#smart
JJ
Jess J
Verified Review
KM
Kristine M
Verified Review
#lovestory
#girlsnight
BS
Brittany S
Verified Review
#lovestory
#greatcast
#datenight
#allthefeels
#girlsnight
GH
Gail H
Verified Review
#lovestory
#predictable
#familyfriendly
#greatcast
#hilarious
BD
Brittany D
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#<3
#clever
#greatcast
AE
Alyce E
Verified Review
#lovestory
#allthefeels
#great
JM
Johanna M
Verified Review
JL
JoLynn L
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#familyfriendly
#greatcast
SH
Steven H
Verified Review
MM
Michael M
Verified Review
#girlsnight
#lovestory
#familyfriendly
CJ
Carmen J
Verified Review
#lovestory
#great
#greatcast
KK
Kecia K
Verified Review
#lovestory
#girlsnight
#familyfriendly
#<3
#slow
#greatcast
RA
Rubia A
Verified Review
#datenight
#lovestory
#girlsnight
JC
James R C
Verified Review
#lovestory
#mustsee
NE
Naomi E
Verified Review
#lovestory
FO
Fabiola O
Verified Review
MK
Melanie K
Verified Review
#lovestory
RS
Roger S
Verified Review
#familyfriendly
#greatcast
DH
Derek H
Verified Review
#lovestory
#<3
#allthefeels
#greatcast
RH
Rolake H
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#socute
PB
Paul B
Verified Review
PW
Paula W
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#familyfriendly
#great
#allthefeels
#girlsnight
PY
Paul Y
Verified Review
CD
Chris D
Verified Review
#lovestory
#greatcast
#predictable
#familyfriendly
#girlsnight
AA
Angie A
Verified Review
#lovestory
#greatcast
RM
Rochelle M
Verified Review
GM
George M
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#predictable
#<3
#hilarious
#girlsnight
EA
Emily A
Verified Review
#lovestory
#datenight
#familyfriendly
#great
#girlsnight
BM
Bonnie M
Verified Review
#smart
#inspiring
#familyfriendly
#<3
#girlsnight
#lovestory
#great
#greatcast
#datenight
#allthefeels
JM
Jed M

Metacritic

60
Aug 26, 2022

Mr Malcolm’s List plays like Jane Austen fan-fiction, which isn’t the worst subgenre in the world, even if nobody could ever confuse the plot with that of Lady Susan, let alone Pride and Prejudice.

Tara Brady
The Irish Times
67
Jun 28, 2022

It’s a pleasant enough diversion, that will likely be best remembered for colorblind casting done right.

Metacritic review by Martin Tsai
Martin Tsai
The A.V. Club
63
Jun 22, 2022

What is here –a good if not “all star” cast, colorful characters, the settings and the story — has charm enough to get by even if no one will ever confuse Mr. Malcolm’s List for “Sense Sensibility.”

Metacritic review by Roger Moore
Roger Moore
Movie Nation