Renee was awesome!!

It was depressing

Loved it!! Give Renee an Oscar!!!

Renae deserves the Academy Award!

An emotionally gripping story. This performance puts her in the Oscar hunt for sure!

Went with the wife. As soon as the lights dimmed I feel asleep. I woke up and my wife was gone.

Great movie!

Zellweger was great. But, it was hard to watch someone destroy herself.

Renee embodies what Judy was in that point of time. Watching the movie, I forget it's Renee Zellweger. The transitions between past and present was done well, it captured the essence of how Judy was as a teen to her adulthood as a mother. Definitely worth seeing whether you're a fan of Judy Garland or Renee Zellweger.

Everyone in this movie gave great performances. Renee Zellweger was absolutely wonderful!

Renee Zellewegger was fairly decent as Judy, though her singing voice left something to be desired in a few songs...and I don't think that was intentional. But it was still interesting seeing and learning about Judy's twilight in London.

Renee Z killed it again, just like she did in ‘Chicago’!!! Riveting performance. It was completely mesmerizing. Never mind that it’s depressing, my goodness. It chronicles the final stretch of her declining popularity as a performer, juxtaposed with her rise as ‘Dorothy’ and the psychological programming of her childhood.

Great film

So many times Ms. Zellweger looked just like Judy and her singing terrific.

Renee was incredible!

Great music, Zellwigger was awesome as Judy Garland. Movie itself was a bit slow moving. I’d see it again for the music.

great story about judy Garland in her post WOZ years

Although very sad I think Renee did an amazing job portraying Judy Garland. It’s a must see. Ms. Garland loved her fans and us fans continue to live her to.

I was greatly moved at this tribute.

Rene was great

Wasn’t planning on seeing it this soon, but the wife crashed at so decided i would. It was a tad on the slow side—but that’s kind of to be expected, but it really was a beautifully tragic story and Renee Zellweger was phenomenal. I would not be surprised if she, at the very least, gets an Oscar nod.

a truly great movie!

Very authentically portrayed. Renee did a great job.

Extraordinary Movie!!

Renee's singing voice was ok, but it couldn't live up to Judy's singing voice.

Moving biopic about a specific period in the life of Judy Garland, with flashbacks to her adolescence. Worth seeing.

Renee IS Judy! She was unbelievable. Sad story but extremely well acted. #Tears

Renee Zellqeger, was outstanding! She portrayed Judy Garland to a T! You should definitely be nominated for an academy award performance! All cast were excellant! What a sad life Judy had to endure

Very well done. Really captures the periods.

Zellweger is outstanding in mimicking Just Garlands mannerisms.

Although Judy doesn’t adhere rigorously to the chronology of the main character’s last months, it provides a compelling portrait of the tragic decline of one of America’s 20th century icons.

James Berardinelli

ReelViews

Renée Zellweger can reach all the notes and hit all the marks, but Garland’s intense emoting eludes her.

Keith Uhlich

Slant Magazine

It’s an intriguing idea that results in a painfully by-the-books biopic. That being said, a gusty, heartbreaking turn from Renée Zellweger makes the exercise worth sitting through.

Caroline Siede

The A.V. Club