Atom User Reviews for Ghost in the Shell
Starting 15mins of movie is good then some action sences and the concept of the movie is really nice
the movie was taken far from the originality and added bits and pieces of the movie here and there for some cliche effect. very disappointed.
Visually stunning. That's about it. Lacking substance, especially if you've seen the original 1995 movie - many of the scenes are recreated exactly.
too long that got lost and forget the theme
Not worth your time or money
I enjoyed it stayed true to the anime
not really close to the original
Movie was alright. Lacked depth and a better plot. Had some "wtf" moments. Overall a 3 out of 5 mainly because it wasn't boring but it lacked in everything but concept. Was disappointed because there was so much potential and so little of that potential fulfilled. The…
While it's a cool concept, its the execution that failed. I feel like all aspects went more into the look of the film rather than actual character and plot depth.
must see in 3d worth the money
While not 100% faithful to the original, the artistic styling and breath taking cinematography made this a must watch for those looking for The anime's heart so to speak, while the story holds both good and bad choices. Overall I left feeling satisfied and a bit hungry for…
Very true to the anime original.
love Scarllet.. great curves!!
Much better than all the haters are saying. Still could have been better.
If you like the anime, check it out.
It was an ok movie. Got bored while I was watching it. Kinda wish the storyline was better.
Though it's not the same as the original, it was still good and a good homage to the original. I was skeptical of ScarJo as Major, but I think she sold it. Also with the whole whitewashing thing, yes I thought that too, but it is a very niche movie. Having a big name…
For what it was it was a good movie. Very visually stunning and good action. Don't expect the original and you'll have a good time
As someone who has yet to watch any of the animated series or movies (Which is highly surprising) is was a very tasteful movie. As someone who will watch the animated series and movies... i'm in for disappointment!
Don't expect to feel Happy, NOT a happy movie, but GOOD!
Hollywood should NOT cast white actors for Asian source materials
Great performances all around, casting was perfectly done. Great action scenes and special effects. I wish they would've pushed the envelope a little more, good movie with room to expand and improve on.
i was disappointed but they tried.
It was ok. Nice visuals but actors didn't fit the story.
Great flick!
Good movie!
Something would change from the Manga but most of all I was a good movie.
Don't listen to what lame review sites have said this is a great movie!
I thought the movie was to long and boring.
I really enjoyed the source material - I feel there were snippets of potential that could gave really been something great. The writing killed "what could have been".
Better than critics made it out to be.
i enjoyed the visuals and action.
All of the stars!
I loved the post futuristic design
A stunning visual adaptation, but is mediocre in substance and emotion despite potential.
Legitimately good. Dabbles into philosophy but not over bearing
About as true to its source material, as the anime was to the manga as source material. visually mind blowing in every conceivable way, and well done in readapting the story.
Scarlett really got into character for this role, she really walked and moved like she had robotic limbs. And while the plot of the movie didn't go exactly like the anime, the changes added a lot more depth to the character.
A grossly under rated movie that is only being held back by people failing to respect it a different interpretation of a revered (and ongoing) story.
I just wasn't feeling it. Like it's ok.
Sometimes it seems that the people who love those "hidden gems", as in the case of Anime, are their worst enemies. This adaptation of the beloved movie /manga/anime, is perfect for its introduction to mainstream Western audiences. It is provocative and carries the message…
Kept true to the anime
It leaved up to the expect
It's like the new girl in school. Definitely nice to look at, but once you actually have a conversation with her, you completely lose interest as she lacks substance upstairs.
amazing visuals
Not especially interesting. Making the whitewashing into an actual plot point was a mistake.
best movie ever it's on point
Great movie, kind of slow when start but the movie avance and get interested and the effects are awesome.
should od done better job with the movie
Amazing!
Metacritic
Ghost in the Shell looks great, sounds great and has a gaping hole at its center — where its emotional core should be.
It is this rage for authenticity, more than the leading lady, that transforms Ghost in the Shell into an American product. Here’s an irony: if anything preserves the unnerving quiddity and strangeness of the Japanese movie, it is Johansson.
This version may not break new ground, but it revisits familiar territory with a vibrant sense of style and welcome restraint. It exemplifies the kind of respectable and utterly unnecessary remake that now defines the Hollywood business model.
