Kaphar’s film bloats its runtime, with a handful of conversations going back for seconds on a full stomach, but it still manages to be utterly moving, entrusting its cast completely with carrying its ideas to touching fruition.

Peyton Robinson

RogerEbert.com

A magnificent showing from Titus Kaphar and his talented cast, Exhibiting Forgiveness is a complicated and beautiful film that is masterfully crafted.

Kaphar brings something special, narratively raw, but thematically refined to his first feature.

William Bibbiani

TheWrap