Atom User Reviews for Eternity

4.6
48
20
4
0
0
POPULAR TAGS
JC
James Alphonse Gericho Castillo
#hilarious
#surprising
#lovestory

Romantic Comedies are back

EF
Emma Ferguson
#mustsee
#clever

Such an original idea! I feel like lately there are a lot of recycled plot lines, but this felt so fun and different. I don’t think the language and sex scenes are ever needed but will definitely be watching many more times on Vidangel!

AJ
Ale Jones
#lovestory
#greatcast
#allthefeels

Phenomenal! Definitely a must see and expect many Oscars and Golden Globe for actors, writers and wardrobes !! A+

CJ
CJ Juneja
#greatcast

Great movie! unique concept. one of the fine movies from A24 in recent times. Keep it up.

AB
Austin Barlow
#allthefeels
#original
#greatcast

Really enjoyed this movie. I liked that it was truly a new movie, not just a remake. The story was well written and the acting was great!

JM
Janny Matos
#smart
#different
#greatcast

It was a more unique take on the afterlife. I think the actors and storyline were good. Still more put together and well done than rom coms nowadays. Can’t ask for much more.

NK
Nick Kisel
#datenight
#greatvisualfx
#smart

Incredible! Multiverses might be overplayed and the comedy was a little annoying starting off, but I was hooked by the story, loved the soundtrack, and left with a lot of what if possibilities to discuss.

NY
Nehizena Young-Edo

This movie was so beautiful and really makes you think the full potential of “true love” and “till death do us part”. I really appreciated its heartwarming story and being in love where it grows and matures and becames an intangible part of our souls and what we carry as we…

AH
Ann Hymas

Good cast but story is not very encouraging about an afterlife. Could have written a more satisfying ending.

IW
Ian Watson

A good movie. Could have been great… but at least it’s good.

CB
Cynthia Birth
#mustsee
#original
#girlsnight
LJ
Laura Jennings
#mustsee
#original
#allthefeels
RM
reyna mazariegos
#surprising
#heartpounding
#original
YK
Yasmin Kenny
#clever
#lovestory
#fantasy
MS
Michelle Soriano
#lovestory
#datenight
#greatcast
SW
Sieira Witthar
#mustsee
#lovestory
#allthefeels
EV
Efrain Vicenteno
#datenight
#mustsee
#allthefeels
MW
Melissa Wittemann
#datenight
#hilarious
#lovestory
VS
Vickie & Rhett Sears
#clever
#inspiring
#original
AS
Anjali Smedley
#lovestory
#hilarious
#datenight
LH
Lorene Head
#lovestory
#clever
MF
Maria Fuentes
#allthefeels
#lovestory
#greatcast
TE
Theja Electric
#lovestory
#great
#allthefeels
OA
Olu Adedapo
#clever
ZC
Zeltzin C
#datenight
#original
#greatcast
ML
Mark Locricchio
#datenight
#greatcast
VJ
Vishrut Jha
#datenight
#lovestory
#mustsee
AK
Ali Kendrick
#lovestory
#hilarious
#greatcast
NG
Nicolas Garcia
#clever
#inspiring
#original
SS
Sayda Sao
#datenight
#original
#lovestory
CW
Chris Woodley
#hilarious
#original
#great
BJ
Brett Johnson
#allthefeels
#lovestory
#clever
DB
Dernelle Brown
#lovestory
#original
#allthefeels
MS
Margareth Soriano
#clever
#inspiring
#mustsee
MC
Molly Chapman
#greatcast
#allthefeels
#original
EC
Erick Chavez
#allthefeels
#datenight
#lovestory
SB
Shunsuke Baba
EM
Elaina Mirabal
#hilarious
#mustsee
#allthefeels
JP
Jake Petruzzelli
#datenight
#hilarious
#lol
JS
Joshua Setow
#lol
#heartpounding
#original
JW
Janene Wilson
CY
Cameron Younger
BW
Ben Witt
JC
JW Chan
FS
Frank Sandoval
AP
Angel Peterson
#datenight
#original
#smart
PP
Parker Pilgrim
MR
Michelle Rodriguez
KT
Kenny Tran
AP
Alberto Pineda

Metacritic

60
Nov 29, 2025

A charming Elizabeth Olsen must choose between two men in the afterlife. The trouble with this often-beguiling romp is that it takes an eternity to wrap up. Too bad no one ever learns how to quit while they’re ahead.

Peter Travers
The Travers Take
88
Nov 25, 2025

It’s quirky, a little unpredictable, and never feels like warmed-over leftovers. There’s a bite to things – an edginess that doesn’t cut too deeply but keeps the sentimentality in check. One of the year’s most pleasant surprises.

Metacritic review by James Berardinelli
James Berardinelli
ReelViews
60
Nov 25, 2025

Hard to ding something for wanting to be a cult rom-com so badly, especially when it’s so well-acted.

Metacritic review by David Fear
David Fear
Rolling Stone