Who Killed These Women? (The Tinley Park 5)

An examination into the largest unsolved mass shooting in modern day America today. On Feb 2, 2008 a killer executed 5 women inside a Lane Bryant department… More Details »

Showtimes
Movie Details

Find Movie Theaters & Showtimes

for

near

We didn't find this title in your area

Browse Local Theaters

Videos & Photos

Movie Info & Cast

Release Date:

Feb 3, 2026

Synopsis

An examination into the largest unsolved mass shooting in modern day America today. On Feb 2, 2008 a killer executed 5 women inside a Lane Bryant department store in suburban Chicago. 1 person managed to survive as she shifted her head.

Moviegoers are saying

Director Charlie Minn's documentary about an unsolved murder case has sparked fierce debate among audiences who appreciate the important story being told but are appalled by the filmmaker's questionable execution and intrusive interviewing style. The film's bizarre opening with a 5-minute ad reel for the director's other projects and cringe-worthy reenactments have left viewers questioning whether they're watching the wrong movie entirely.

Top Mentions

Cringe-Worthy

Self-Promotional

Exploitation-Alert

Amateur-Hour

Controversy-Magnet

Train-Wreck

Summary generated from the text of Atom User reviews

Letterboxd User Reviews

N/A

RATINGS N/A FANS

Feb 13, 2026

I knew I was in for a special treat when the first 4 minutes of this film were an ad for this guys OTHER projects on Amazon

6 Likes

Matt Rasmussen

Feb 15, 2026

Terrible documentary. The first 5 minutes of the movie is an ad for the director’s other movies. I literally thought the theatre played the wrong movie. The “reactment” was a joke. A jr high school could have done a better job. I also don’t believe the questions were…

3 Likes

John Cataldo

Apr 17, 2026

This is genuinely atrocious. Why does it start with an ad for another movie?? The reenactment is embarrassingly bad. A 12 year old could’ve made a better one. The documentary make comes off so sleazy in all the interviews. He asks terrible questions. It’s actually…

1 Likes

Siun
Feb 13, 2026

I thought I was in the wrong movie when there was the lifetime movie remake at the beginning

3 Likes

mlelsr

Mar 28, 2026

I'm losing it.Cool to see a movie that's only showing at my theater in the entire country for the time being. I respect the director a lot and think it's really cool he got to put something like this in a theater for a roadshow-style distribution. The good first--I believe…

2 Likes

faceless_entity

Feb 19, 2026

this dragged. very important and tragic story, but a poorly made documentary. the director/interviewer asked the family members and related people, who were not at the crime scene, speculative and leading questions while also interrupting them when they tried to give an…

2 Likes

momallow
Feb 19, 2026

I’m glad this story was able to be told. You can tell the family members and friends have tried hard to find peace in this. I feel like the director was trying to push true crime theories on the story and family members which I felt was unnecessary and I felt very bad for…

1 Likes

zoessmith9

Feb 17, 2026

It does the best it can with what it has. Just not very organized in its performance and the director would greatly benefit from some stronger journalistic instincts.

1 Likes

Jimmy

Apr 15, 2026

Baffling. 2/10

0 Likes

Brian Stevenson