I Can Only Imagine 2
-
Showtimes
-
Movie Details
Videos & Photos
Movie Info & Cast
Synopsis
Bart Millard, lead singer of MercyMe, faces a personal crisis at the peak of his success. As his world unravels, he struggles with his beliefs and inner demons while seeking a path through adversity.
Cast
- Milo Ventimiglia
- Dennis Quaid
- Arielle Kebbel
- Sophie Skelton
- John Michael Finley
- Trace Adkins
- Jobie James
- Anjelah Johnson-Reyes
- Jason Burkey
- Sammy Dell
Moviegoers are saying
This Christian sequel strikes an emotional chord with audiences who praise Milo Ventimiglia's standout performance as Tim Timmons, though critics remain divided on its heavy-handed messaging. While faith-based audiences are reaching for tissues and declaring it better than the original, skeptics find the execution vapid despite acknowledging improved filmmaking over typical Christian cinema fare.
Top Mentions
Summary generated from the text of Atom User reviews
Letterboxd User Reviews
3.3
2.3K
1.1K
730
- Feb 28, 2026
While tecnically a sequel, I see this film as more of a continuation of a man's life. Whether you a person of faith or not, we are not guaranteed an easy road. Our family can get sick, friends can sick, and hardships can often feel likr more than one can bear. Yet we have…
Robert ShupeFeb 19, 2026WAIT…it’s possible to make a GOOD Christian movie?!!
CinemaFan007Feb 21, 2026An emotionally resonant and powerful sequel. A lot of what made the first one so good stays for this sequel. The performances are good, especially Ventimiglia’s as Tim Timmons, who was a great addition to the cast and one of my favorite parts of the film. His story was…
JohnSimpson - Feb 21, 2026
Considerably better than the first I Can Only Imagine, dropping the cringey humor and origin story tropes in favor of a much more interesting examination of where a career goes after your band achieves one-hit wonder status in the cult of Christian propaganda. Even if this…
Aaron BartuskaFeb 19, 2026ik i was supposed to be emotionally involved but the every time Milo was onscreen i could only hear “WHY did you DROP outta YALE?!”
itskendallfaithFeb 20, 2026Solid film from start to finish, I got bored in the middle and a minute later Milo Ventimiglia delivers an Oscar worthy monologue, the end was phenomenal. My gripes are his son's moment on stage singing alone was not good, and seemed like it only served as a warm up to the…
W4v3sBy3 - Feb 20, 2026
as a “this is us” fan, the hospital scene had me stressed thinking something was going to happen to milo ventimiglia again
autumnFeb 20, 2026My mom loved it! The lady behind me, who was humming and saying “mhmm” throughout the whole movie, must have been moved by the messaging, I assume. The church group at the back, who loudly talked and clapped during the film, probably loved it too. Sadly, it treats the…
KFFeb 19, 2026Sammy Dell was channeling his inner Tom Holland and Mason Thames the entire time.
Fugi456
Queue Community Reviews
95%
Community 195
Top Reviews
- Mateo likedI Can Only Imagine 2
Really good for a sequel, but not as good as the first one. Another strong and emotional true story that leads to a beautiful ending. There are a few slow parts and iffy writing, but it doesn’t take away from the whole movie. I like how it explores more people as well. 6.5/10
Sherilee Nimon lovedI Can Only Imagine 2A great real life story about how God is working even if the answer is wait or no.
Joshua Childress lovedI Can Only Imagine 2If you want to cry the whole movie then this emotional rollercoaster is for you!!!
- Kelsey Blankenship lovedI Can Only Imagine 2
Love. Love. Love. Love!!! Possibly even better than the first!
Glenda Wharff lovedI Can Only Imagine 2Surprisingly just as good as the first one
Ana lovedI Can Only Imagine 2Such a beautiful movie, enjoyed it a lot
- Grace McDorman lovedI Can Only Imagine 2
Everyone has struggled
Sparkinator likedI Can Only Imagine 2Great movie!
Atom Users Reviews
POPULAR TAGS
Reviews
- KMKay Manning
Absolutely fabulous, heart wrenching, inspiring and beautiful at the same time, bring your Kleenex box!
EAEmily AmersonAbsolutely Amazing! Would highly recommend!
VHVicki HudsonGet's a 10 rating for me. Better than the first one. Truly inspirational.
- BCBrigette Cecil
Loved this movie! I cried, I laughed. Wonderful story. I recommend for sure!
ABAlara B.Somehow even more powerful than the original! I would watch this again and again
JSJoy StokesIt was touching and something everyone can relate to in various seasons in life.
- RMRobert Manger
Great message! Inspiring
JSJanice SibertGreat movie
CWCarmen WrightGreat movie!
Metacritic
Feb 20, 2026
This movie is designed for an audience already dedicated to the music of Millard and Timmons, and to the particular Christian tradition they represent. Those who are already fans will appreciate this chance to share his story, but those who do not know him may find it uninspiring.
Nell Minow
RogerEbert.com
Feb 19, 2026
Ventimiglia becomes the sequel’s saving grace.
Lisa Kennedy
The New York Times
Feb 19, 2026
Laborious and dull, I Can Only Imagine 2 only comes to life in the comedic scenes featuring Ventimiglia, who buries his handsomeness in a buzz-cut, full beard, and Buddy Holly-style glasses to resemble Timmons.
Frank Scheck
The Hollywood Reporter
Full Screen Image Viewer
Target Exclusive Showing
Don't Have The Password?