The film centers around two all-American high school jocks Brad and Dylan who are out for a night on the town when they are approached by the beautiful and seductive Meg at a local bar. Ready for what they hope will be a night to remember, the guys are subsequently kidnapped, drugged and awaken tied up face to face in an abandoned pool in the middle of nowhere. Absurdity and insanity ensue as we learn that Orin, Meg's overly flamboyant brother has been the target of Brad and Dylan's homophobic bullying and that Meg is actually a grad student who plans to perform a psychological and somewhat sadistic experiment on them as part of her thesis, which poses the question, "is homosexuality a choice"