A good supporting cast — including Isiah Whitlock Jr., Harris Yulin, Tom Everett Scott and Josh Lucas as a hindrance to John’s plans — gives Kelly much to play off, but the story is too rote to get worked up about any of the conflicts.

Kevin Crust

Los Angeles Times

Hyams directs Timothy Brady’s script appropriately if not brilliantly (Hyams is also credited as a co-editor), but the movie’s main attraction, finally, is its cast.

Glenn Kenny

The New York Times

Away from the baseball diamond, All Square effectively pivots to moments of surprisingly affecting drama.

Joe Leydon

Variety